Wednesday 15 October 2008

Gordon and Sammy discuss Dark Isle

Gordon: I don’t think D.A Nelson should have mixed factual characters and fictional creatures. Sammy: I think that it was a great idea!!!
Gordon: Maybe, but it was a bit confusing.
Sammy: I don’t think it was confusing at all because when you get into the book a little bit you forget that the dodo and dragon are extinct or never existed. Anyway in the story the dragon is a stone statue and then it turns into a real live thing.
Gordon: Even so I think they could’ve have been described a bit more.
Sammy: I know but I think it was a good idea to let you imagine the dragon and the dodo and the rat.
Gordon: Maybe but some people who don’t have a big imagination might have found it hard.
Sammy: Well maybe then the book isn’t for them because halfway through it some parts left you wondering what was going to happen later on in the story with these amazing characters.
Gordon: Yes but in the awards the book should be for most people in that age group.
Sammy: Good point but I think that most people would like it.
Gordon: Yes but the book award is for the best book that everyone will like not just a small portion.
Sammy: well then Dark Isle would be a clear winner then!!!

By Gordon and Sammy - Royal Rumblers

No comments: